This Complex Life

Why Men Don’t Ask for Help With Their Mental Health

Listen

You sleep through the night and still wake up tired. You’re snapping at your partner over small things, the weekend comes and goes without anything feeling good, and somewhere along the way you decided this is just what being a grown up feels like. A lot of men live like this for a long time, and it isn’t always because they’re too proud to get support. It has often never occurred to them that it could feel any different.

That was the starting point for my conversation with Amal Saleh-Zada, a Registered Counsellor on our team at The Therapy Hub in Melbourne’s west. Amal has been on the podcast before, when we talked about stigma and supporting young men’s emotional and mental health. This time we wanted to look at the other things that get in the way.

 

Why men don’t ask for help: you don’t know what you don’t know

Amal told me about a friend who had headaches every day, all the way through school and into university. Nobody said anything, so he assumed headaches were something you put up with. Eventually someone suggested an eye test and it turned out he needed glasses. His normal had been a daily headache and he had nothing to compare it to.

Amal’s own version of this happened in a counselling class. He’d gone back to uni as a mature age student, and while the class was working through the symptoms of anxiety he started recognising his own body in the list. He was 29. Until then he’d assumed everyone’s mind raced when they put their head down at night, and finding out that some people just go to sleep was news to him.

We’re warned when we study psychology and counselling not to go around diagnosing ourselves and everybody we know. I think there’s a difference between doing that and having language for an experience you didn’t know was different, or could be easier. Amal runs Youth Mental Health First Aid training in schools, and he told me the figure he stops on every time is that 43 per cent of young people don’t get help because they don’t know any different.

Common doesn’t mean it’s okay

Feeling alone with something can leave you thinking you’re broken. Then you start talking to other people, find out plenty of them are struggling too and decide it must be normal. Lots of people struggle, and that can be really common. It doesn’t mean that’s how it has to be. I think of the book The Myth of Normal here.

 

Why anger is easier than sadness for men and boys

Amal had been in a Year 7 classroom that day talking about emotions, and he’d asked the students why it’s easier for some people to let anger through than sadness. One of the girls said it’s because anger feels stronger, and she was spot on. Sadness leaves you vulnerable and anger feels like control. In my experience there’s a gender difference in what gets punished too. Girls get told off for being angry and boys get told off for being sad.

What I’d love is for men to get angry at the system that told them not to feel things. That same system makes it harder to connect with your kids and your partner, and what gets pushed down tends to come out as drinking, drug use, violence, anger or depression that can be paralysing. If you’re going to be bold and courageous, aim it there.

 

Alcohol, numbing and men’s mental health

Amal hears people say they’re not okay with taking prescribed medication while being comfortable having a few drinks to get to sleep. One comes with a label and the other is socially acceptable. I’ve worked with people where it slips under the radar. It’s a couple of beers after work, then one when they get home, then another one or two. Over time it takes away how available you are, and you end up alive but not living.

A lot of guys come to therapy because of conflict. They don’t want to keep fighting with their partner, or their partner has told them to go. The ones who don’t come as often are lonely, and they’re missing out on being the kind of dad they want to be. Often they just don’t know anything could be different, because this is what their dad did, or their brother, or the guys at football and at work.

None of this is about judging anyone. Amal shared a case study from his degree that has stayed with him. A researcher asked a man to describe the first time he took heroin, and he said it felt like being young and sick with a cold, and his mum bringing him soup, putting a blanket around him and giving him a warm hug. People do these things for a reason. They’re carrying pain and they’ve found something that takes it away for a while, even when it costs them their body, their mind and their relationships.

 

Signs your mental health needs attention

Amal’s marker is three to four weeks. Everyone gets knocked around by life, and if you haven’t bounced back in that time it’s a sign to look closer. The two things he tells people to watch are sleep and relationships. Sleep that doesn’t leave you refreshed, nothing to look forward to, no moments of happiness and a scattered mind that can’t get to the things that are important to you are all good indicators. I’d add conflict to that list. If you’re easily irritated, short tempered and reacting in ways that don’t feel like you, pay attention to it.

 

When to see a GP or counsellor

If any of that describes your last month, talk to your GP about a referral, book in with a counsellor or call your work EAP. Amal and the rest of our team see people in person and online at The Therapy Hub. If you’re the partner of someone who has shut down and you’d like a way to start talking again, my open ended questions for couples are a simple place to start, and Relationship Reset is there when you’re ready for something more structured.

Amal finished with a message for men that I loved. It takes a lot of strength and courage to step forward and say something is affecting me and I’m not going to let it take control of my life. You can use the stubbornness you already have.

Read The Full Transcript

EXPAND TO READ

[00:00]

Marie: Hello, and welcome back to This Complex Life. I have with me a return guest. In our last episode we talked about stigma and men seeking mental health support, and all of the things that go along with that. I am welcoming back to the podcast Amal. Welcome, Amal.

Amal: Hi, Marie. Thank you so much for having me on again.

Marie: A lot has changed since our last episode.

Amal: I can’t remember how long it’s been, but one little bundle of joy has joined our lives. She’s just turned 14 months, so she’s keeping us on our toes. It’s been an amazing experience, but also some sleepless nights, including last night.

Marie: Never fun, I imagine. She’s super cute.

Amal: She is. She makes up for it.

Marie: Last time we spoke, we talked about stigma being one of the things that prevent men from seeking help, and we’ll put a link to that episode in the show notes. I wanted to revisit some of those themes, but we had a bit of a chat before we pressed record about some of the other reasons that prevent men from seeking support for their mental health.

Marie: What are some of the things you notice that might prevent men from reaching out? Either some of the men that you’ve worked with, or friends and family. There are a lot of myths out there, and we know that men in particular find it more difficult to access mental health support. Tell me about it.

Amal: As we were just chatting about earlier, Marie, one of the most common things, based on my own experience, is that we quite often don’t know what we don’t know. What our normal is, is based purely on what we know. For example, I was talking to you about one of my teacher friends. He got all the way to uni and he had headaches. Nobody had said anything to him, and he thought that was something he just had to cope with. Then finally somebody said, “Maybe you should get your eyes tested.” When he did, it turned out he needed glasses. For him, his normal was headaches every day. I’m surprised he got through schooling and went on to become a teacher. That’s just one example with other men.

[02:00]

Amal: Something I can personally reflect on is going back to uni late as a mature age student and sitting in one of my counselling classes. We were learning about mental health in one of the units, and I started looking through the symptoms of anxiety. I was working through assignments back then, and I could relate to the experience of what goes on. I started to pay more attention to my body. I thought, “Hold on a second. All of these things happen, and it’s constant, and it usually spikes when this happens.” I was around 29 years old before I realised, hold on a second, I’ve got anxiety.

Amal: I didn’t pay much attention to it because I thought that was normal for everyone. When I found out there are people out there who put their heads down and go to sleep, and their mind doesn’t race, there’s no constant hamster on the wheel situation, for me that was not normal.

Marie: That’s a really interesting thing to come to, because we’re warned when we study psychology and counselling not to diagnose ourselves and everybody else. There’s a difference between diagnosing and thinking, “Oh, this family member definitely has this thing,” and having a language to describe an experience that you didn’t know was maybe different, or could have been easier, or might be getting in the way of your day to day activities.

Marie: I guess what you’re saying is there are a lot of people out there who might be carrying a heaviness, something like a mental illness or even just fluctuating mental health, and they might have no idea that they don’t need to feel that way.

Amal: Absolutely. It’s not knowing that I don’t have to be carrying this. At the moment, in one of the schools that I work at, I’m running the Youth Mental Health First Aid training. Quite often our educators think kids do this for attention. When I get to the stats, I make a point of stopping on the one that says 43 per cent of young people don’t get help because they don’t know. They don’t know any different. They don’t know what’s meant to be good mental health and what is not so good mental health.

[04:00]

Amal: Because we’re so used to just carrying on and dealing with those situations, most of us for all our lives, we don’t know any different. That awareness, as you said, isn’t diagnosing. It’s asking the question, hold on a second, is this what people are meant to feel or carry?

Marie: Yeah, and feeling alone is a really dangerous thing, because it can leave you feeling maybe broken or somehow other. Until you start talking to other people or hearing other people’s stories, you don’t know that your experience isn’t normal. Common doesn’t mean it’s okay. Lots of people can be struggling, and that can be really common, but we also don’t want to make that the norm. I think of the book The Myth of Normal. A lot of us can be really struggling, and it can seem really common. It doesn’t mean that’s how it has to be.

Amal: Absolutely. I could not agree more. Just because it happens often, or we see it more often now, doesn’t mean that’s okay or that’s how we should be living our lives.

Marie: Your first educational experience was in engineering, then you moved into counselling, and now there are a few other things on the horizon. You are perhaps more open to mental health support than other men your age. Has that changed in some of the friendship groups that you’re in? What do you see in men and young men through the work you do in schools or through The Therapy Hub, and maybe in their dads? What’s changing or not changing in how we talk about mental health support?

Amal: The biggest difference, I think, Marie, is having more and more men stepping forward, acknowledging it and normalising those conversations, talking about how common it is and the impact that it has.

[06:00]

Amal: For example, I was in a classroom with Year 7s today. We were talking about controlling emotions, and why it’s easier for some people to let anger through rather than sadness. One of the young girls said, “Because it feels stronger.” I said, “Spot on.” Quite often there are certain feelings we don’t want to admit to, because they make us feel vulnerable, or they don’t make us feel like we’re in control, or we’re not really comfortable having those emotions. Sometimes we end up masking those emotions with something else where we feel like we’ve got a little bit more control, or emotions that are a little bit more acceptable in our view.

Marie: Yeah. I can understand anger seeming more powerful and sadness being very vulnerable. In my experience there’s a gender difference there as well. Girls get told off for being angry and boys might get told off for being sad.

Amal: Yes. Just a situation last week. Two boys, good friends, Year 11s, were having an argument. I asked one of them, “What happened?” He said, “We were playing, he pushed me, but he used too much strength and pushed me over and I fell, and I told him I’m not okay with it.” His friend started getting annoyed and said, “Why are you not okay with it? We were just playing.” He was saying, “I’m not saying that you did it deliberately. What I’m telling you is you ended up going too far.” In his mind, the friend was struggling to acknowledge that what he was doing caused an undesired effect. Rather than acknowledging that maybe he did overdo it, he was being confronted with something he didn’t want to accept within himself.

Amal: I think that’s a similar situation, where there are certain things we want to accept and that are expected of us, especially in boys. Speaking of more traditional views, being tough or being angry is seen as a sign of masculinity. I think that’s historical in most cultures, where anger is seen as belonging with men, manly men or macho men. Anger is part of it.

[08:00]

Marie: It’s funny you say that. I never get into fights with clients, and they’re already in my therapy room, so they’ve already broken down some of those barriers. I wish some men would get angry about a system that has told them not to feel feelings, that it’s somehow bad. If you’re going to be angry and you’re going to be bold and courageous, break the system that has kept you holding all of this on your own.

Marie: That to me is such a sad reality. There’s a strength that is supposed to be there, but not to challenge the system that is also really screwing them. It’s making it hard for men to connect with their children or their partners, or to suppress emotions that come out in drug and alcohol use, or in violence, or in anger, or in deep depression that can be paralysing. I wish you could activate and redirect some of that strength and anger to making it easier for men to speak up. That’s just one of my little rants. As a man yourself, because clearly I’m not one, what do you think of something like that?

Amal: Marie, you’re so spot on. One of the most common things, especially when it comes to mental health, is medication. Quite often I hear people say, “You know what? I’m not okay with taking medication,” or, “It’s drugs.” Especially with the younger people who try to self medicate.

Marie: Via other drugs?

Amal: Yes, other drugs. I say, “Okay, hold on a second. You’re okay with putting that in your system, and we don’t know the effect of it, or in some cases it has the opposite effect of what you’re wanting. When it comes to the thing that is prescribed and meant to help you, you’re against that.”

[10:00]

Amal: We’re okay with alcohol, for example. We’re okay with marijuana or something else. Different age groups experiment with or take different things, and we’re accepting of that. We’re more open to recreational drugs than, for example, antidepressants, because that comes with the label of depression. “No. I’d rather just drink a few bottles and put myself to sleep, because it’s acceptable.”

Marie: Yeah. I’ve definitely worked with folks who do that, and it can slip under the radar. It might be a couple of beers after work, then maybe one when they get home, and another one or two. Over time it depletes your availability. In a therapy room it’s quite intimate, I get to know some people really well, and I see so much good there. It’s not all lost, but it doesn’t get noticed, because when you’re not available mentally or physically, you’re stuck up in your own head, or you’ve drunk enough beer or wine to numb yourself, you’re alive but not living.

Marie: That can come out in conflict in some cases. A lot of guys come to therapy because of conflict. It’s, “I don’t want to keep fighting with my partner,” or their partner has said, “Go to therapy.” For some, and they’re maybe not the ones who come to see me as often, they are lonely, and they’re missing out on being the kind of dad that they want to be. Maybe they want to do it differently to what they had, and they just don’t know how. I think that’s really sad. They deserve all of this richness in life, but there’s something stopping them. One of those somethings is not knowing that anything could be different, or thinking that’s just what you do, because that’s what my dad did, my brother did, the guys at football or the guys at work. It’s really quite damaging.

Amal: As you said, it’s by no means judging people. If they don’t know any different, they’ll try to manage the pain or the hurt by numbing themselves with whatever means are available to them.

[12:00]

Amal: I think quite often that is the case even with the younger people. They’re carrying pain, they’re carrying hurt, or this heaviness, as you said at the beginning, and they will try to find a way to cope with it. It’s amazing how our brain goes for certain things because of the effect that a particular substance or chemical has on us.

Amal: I remember a case study we looked at when I was doing my degree. A neuropsychologist was studying drugs and why people get addicted to particular drugs but not others. He was interviewing a man, probably in his late twenties or early thirties, and he said, “Describe the first time you took heroin.” The man said, “The first time I took heroin, it felt like I was young, I was sick, I had a cold, and my mum brought me soup and put a blanket around me and gave me a warm hug.”

Amal: That really hit home. Often when we look at people and the things they’re engaging in, we think that they don’t know any different or there’s something wrong with them. They’re doing it for a reason. They’re engaging in those behaviours for a reason. For this person, my heart broke for him. The love that he was seeking through that. Unfortunately, as we know with drugs, once the body builds a tolerance, more and more is required to have the same result. When you see someone going through that, the impact those substances are having on their lives, on their bodies, on their minds and on their relationships is incredibly sad. It is incredibly sad to see people going through so much pain and, at the same time, being judged and blamed for it even more.

[14:00]

Marie: Yeah, that’s a story that will really stick. You’re seeking some sort of support or comfort and have found it in a place that maybe is not a great long term strategy and can be really harmful. For folks listening, what are some of the things they might need to be aware of that might be an indication that things are not okay? What are some general signs or symptoms that you share with people that might be an indication to get a referral from your GP, book in a session with a counsellor or chat to your work EAP? What are some of the go to things that you recommend?

Amal: I would say if something has been carrying on for more than three to four weeks. We all go through life, we all get impacted, there are stresses and challenges. If you haven’t bounced back within three to four weeks, and there’s that heaviness, that sense of this is not me, I’m not really feeling fulfilled, I feel like something is wrong. I think we all, deep down inside, have a bit of a gauge of what it should be like. I think listening to that.

Amal: More practical things. If sleeping is not leaving you refreshed. If you’re not looking forward to anything and there is nothing that brings any joy. It’s not normal to be happy 24/7, but if you’re not able to experience moments of happiness or a sense of fulfilment, because it feels like a constant battle, I think those are good indicators. The two key things that I normally say to look out for is sleep and relationships. If these two things are being affected, then it’s a good idea to ask, “Okay, what’s causing it or what’s contributing to it?”

Marie: Yeah, I think that’s a really good one, and everyone we’ve been speaking to in the series for Mental Health Month has had similar things. Sleeping too much or too little, not feeling rested, feeling lonely or disconnected, that impact on relationships or work. I think I’d add being in conflict to that, so loneliness and conflict. If you’re finding yourself easily irritated or short tempered, they could be some things to look out for too.

Amal: Reactivity. Especially when we know that’s not aligned with who we are. When we go, “Hold on a second. Why am I reacting the way I am?”

[16:00]

Marie: Yeah.

Amal: One more thing I’ll add, Marie, is when we can’t seem to get things done, things that are important, and our mind’s scattered. When we’re not able to focus on the things that are important to us and we can’t bring ourselves to do those things, I would say that’s a really good indicator that something’s not right.

Marie: Yeah, that’s really helpful. Thanks so much for sharing this, Amal. Maybe in another couple of years we’ll get you back on for another update.

Amal: To all the people out there, especially our men, there’s absolutely nothing wrong with it. If anything, as you said, Marie, it takes a lot of strength and courage to step forward to go, “You know what? Something is affecting me, and I’m gonna fight that, and I’m gonna channel my anger, my energy and that stubbornness or perseverance towards something where I go, you know what? I’m not gonna let this take control of my life.”

Marie: Yeah, I love that. Thanks, Amal.

Amal: Thank you very much, Marie. Thanks for having me.

Ask Marie:

Do you have a question you’d like answered on the podcast?

marie finished images